Review: Lottie Dolls are a Win For Kids

Robot Builder. By Lottie.

This holiday season, I will be doing a series of giveaways—all of brands I believe in—brands that seek to empower or support girls in some way.

First up is “Lottie,” which I am happy to introduce to you today. Lottie is a recent arrival in the girls’ fashion doll scene, produced by an indie company in the UK to give girls a healthy doll to play with. I really like what they’re doing.

The dolls’ bodies are modeled after the typical proportions of a 9-year-old girl, and though they’re fashionable, they are not sexualized. The Lottie line launched in 2012 and has since won 12 awards in the USA and UK. Press and blog coverage has been generally positive, though some reviewers of Lottie’s debut offerings wished the line had gone further in defying stereotypes.

Well, good news: The newest dolls introduced a lot of variety to the brand. As co-founder Lucie Follett explained to me, “When we launched Lottie, we wanted to get our product on the shelf, and buyers are reluctant to stock anything without TV advertising, especially from a new brand with no track record or sales.

“Therefore, this stance informs the development process,” Follet continued. “We knew from the get-go that it was necessarily going to have to be an evolutionary process. For various reasons, we could not immediately jump in with the more adventurous doll themes we envisaged for Lottie: As a new, untested independent brand without TV advertising, retailers were unlikely to want to take on anything too radical or extreme.

“Because of this, our doll themes in year one were more conservative than we would have liked. We have since pushed on from our work on body image in year one to create doll themes that we know are much needed and go beyond the conventional stereotypes.”

Now, in addition to the debut collection which featured dolls such as pink-themed “Spring Celebration Ballet Lottie,” “English Country Garden Lottie,” and “Pony Flag Race Lottie,” Lottie now includes a wider color palette and more varied themes. For example, “Robot Girl Lottie” builds robots; “Kawaii Karate Lottie” is inspired by Sensei Debi Steven of London; and “Pirate Queen Lottie” is inspired by the real-life Irish Pirate Queen Grace O’Malley who lived in 16th-century Ireland. (As Follett told me, “Lottie will never be a Princess—but a Queen, yes indeed! They wield power.”)

REVIEW: Arklu sent me three dolls for review: Robot Girl Lottie, Pirate Queen Lottie, and Autumn Leaves Lottie, plus each doll’s accessory pack.

Last night, I convened my “kid test team”—my son T, age 5, and his friend E, age 4—to check them out. (T is usually all about trucks and cars, but when his girl friends come over, he will play dolls with enthusiasm.) E’s mom, Jess, who is a science teacher, also explored the toys with us.

Autumn Leaves Lottie and Biscuit the Beagle Robot Girl Lottie and Busy Lizzie Pirate Queen Lottie and accessories

A box full of Lottie toysWe opened the box together, and E exclaimed, “Oh, they are cool!”  T cooed when he saw the Pirate Queen: “Aw, she’s cuuuuute!” As Jess helped me open all the packages, she commented, “I love that they’re not princesses or divas, and the bodies are very proportional.” But, noting that she is a tree-loving hippie, Jess added: “If they’re advertising that the boxes have minimal plastic, I wish they could have gone further—why are the Autumn girl’s hat and scarf in the box in separate plastic bags, when she could just be wearing them?”

E adored Autumn Leaves Lottie and was eager to explore her outfit and play with her dog, Biscuit. Meanwhile, T enthused over both Pirate Queen Lottie and Busy Lizzie, the robot.

E with Autumn Leaves Lottie and Robot Girl LottieThe kids experimented with everything. E liked the dolls’ clothing and, when I asked if they were easy or tricky to dress and undress, she said that they were pretty easy—“only a little tricky,” which mom Jess appreciated: She said that E can’t dress her Calico Critters on her own.

The clothing seemed to be of good quality; Jess and I liked that Autumn Leaves Lottie’s jacket was soft and felt-like.

We also liked that the dolls were able to hold the pirate cutlass or the leash for Biscuit the Beagle, as so often fashion dolls aren’t able to hold objects.

The dolls’ hair was also lovely—soft and nice to play with. But T remarked, “I wish all of the girls came with a brush for their hair in case it got messed up.” He had me use my fingernails to smooth down Pirate Queen Lottie’s hair several times during play.

We opened Busy Lizzie last, and T and E were fascinated with the idea of building a robot. They enjoyed switching out the robot’s arms and top pieces; T decided that when the robot wore blue hair on top, it was a girl, but that when it wore its little dome with antenna on top, it was a boy.

photo11Lizzie came with a frying pan and spatula (the toy’s back story is that Lottie was building a robot for her science fair and thought it would be great if the robot could help her do chores), and T declared that the yellow arms were for cooking. Although the dolls were easy to dress and undress, it was a little tricky for the kids to force the frying pan and spatula into Lizzie’s hands, and the spatula broke right away. There was also some confusion about the extra set of shoes; we thought they were meant for the robot, but the robot’s shoes don’t come off. They do fit on Lottie, though—and T had fun putting a spare shoe into Lizzie’s central compartment that opens.

When T woke up this morning, he asked if we could play with “the girls” again.
I’m frankly impressed that he has been wanting to play with them today, too. He has never played with dolls independently before—only when girl friends are around. So this is a real first for us. It reminds me of what happens when TV shows featuring girls are done really well: boys defy expectations by enjoying them, too.

When I asked T why he liked them so much, he said, “They have fun things!” Then, he picked up Pirate Queen Lottie and had her say to the other Lotties: “Who wants to find a treasure chest???” The accessory packs are a real hit, adding value to the kids’ imaginative play.

SUMMARY: Lottie is a doll worth recommending—a brand I can believe in. Key points:

  • The body type was created with care. The relationship between dolls and girls’ body image was central to their construction, and I can see this clearly reflected in the product.
  • I liked the themes we were given to review. They were a refreshing change from the fashion-and-shopping orientation of most fashion dolls, and they really engaged the kids’ imaginations.

GIVEAWAY: Would you like a Lottie doll, too? Enter below to win by 11:59 p.m. EST, Friday, November 29! Two winners will be selected; one will receive Pirate Queen Lottie with her accessory pack, and the other will receive Robot Girl Lottie with her accessory, the Busy Lizzie robot. This raffle is open to residents of the continental U.S.A., and the prizes will be sent to the winners by Arklu.

Click here to enter the Lottie Doll giveaway.

Note: I will post a giveaway from another brand I believe in on Saturday, November 30. Be sure to check back!

DISCLOSURE: Although Arklu sent me three Lottie dolls to review, all opinions expressed here are my own and have not been previewed by the Arklu company.


Rebecca Hains is a media studies professor at Salem State University. Follow her on Facebook and Twitter.

30 Comments on “Review: Lottie Dolls are a Win For Kids

  1. Oh these dolls are adorable! c: This coming from a girl who only collects Gothic dolls. xD
    I like the message they send as well. They would definitely fit in with all my other dolls. c:

  2. My daughter would love these! She is very into pirates lately, and also becoming quite the geekling, much to our delight. 🙂

  3. These dolls look so cool. I think my son would love that robot one. That is neat that the robot can be taken apart and have parts traded. Very imaginative. I can’t wait to see what else this company will be creating.

  4. These are so cool! My daughter loves to play pirates and robots right now! I love a doll that can teach girl that fashionable and cool doesn’t mean princess.

  5. These dolls are great! my only comment would be to sell all of the outfits separately. That way, you can pick the Lottie doll (skin/hair color) you most want, but still get all the outfits. My niece would love the Pandora’s Box doll (she loves cats!)

  6. I want the robot Lottie because my daughter is really into building machines!

  7. These are on my list for my daughter for Christmas! Thanks for the review. You really helped finalize that decision! I’d love to win one for her!

  8. My girls have several Lottie dolls on their Christmas wish lists this year, my 10 year old loves the Autumn Leaves doll and my 7 year old cat lover LOVES the Pandora’s box doll. They also love the pet cat and the dog. Fingers crossed, would love to win one for them!!

  9. Pingback: Toy Joy or Consumption Junction? Critical Thinking for Holiday Fun - Shaping Youth

  10. Pingback: Should clothing prices vary by size? | Rebecca Hains

  11. I love these dolls! Such a refreshing change from the other dolls geared towards girls this age. What a great way to teach positive body image!!!

  12. I like both dolls but the pirate one more, love her red hair! BTW in my entry my fb name came out wrong, its Gail Rose Bello

  13. Great review! I just had added these to my wish list the other day, so good timing. I love the unconventional themes for the dolls and of course their bodies looking like little girls, not adults. I will probably order the butterfly rescuer for my older daughter who is very interested in butterflies, and not just because they’re pretty but because they’re fascinating. I think she’d also like the robot builder. 🙂

  14. I love these dolls and the positive messages they send to little girls. I hope they soon make boy dolls and homes for them too!

  15. I love these dolls–how they are mainly proportional and not sexualized. I wish they were around for my now-14yr old dtr! I would love to give the Robot Girl Lottie doll to my 3yr old dtr. I think her brothers would enjoy playing with it & the Busy Lizzie set, too. Thank you for reviewing Lottie dolls! I just learned about them today through an email from Lovetolearn(dot)net, which is a homeschool supply company; I wanted to learn more & your review is the best, most thorough I have read.

  16. I like that these dolls are proportions like little girls. I would love to give my daughter robot builder Lottie

  17. These look fabulous! My 5 year old daughter doesn’t have Barbies, etc. because we have not encouraged them. She would love the Robot and Karate dolls because she can relate to them!

  18. My 8 year old daughter was asking for a Monster High doll for Christmas, but I have to say that both she and her little brother would have more fun with a pirate queen or a robot scientist.

  19. Pingback: Reach and Teach: Get to Know the People Behind the Products - Shaping Youth

  20. Pingback: Reach and Teach: Get to Know the People Behind the Products - Shaping Youth

  21. Pingback: Review and giveaway: Go! Go! Sports Girls dolls are healthy, fun, and inspiring | Rebecca Hains

  22. Pingback: Real Mom Tips (and a GIVEAWAY): Creative Gifts for Kids from Media Culture Expert Rebecca Hains | hello, MAMAS

  23. Pingback: 5 Reasons NOT to Buy Barbie for Little Girls | Rebecca Hains

%d bloggers like this: