Internet mob shames mom in Harambe’s name

The tragic killing of Harambe the gorilla has prompted an international outpouring of grief and rage. Harambe was killed by Cincinnati zoo officials to save the life of a preschooler who somehow entered the gorillas’ enclosure. It’s a decision officials maintain was their only possible course of action, given Harambe’s great strength and the fact that tranquilizers can enrage animals before they take effect.

Since then, more than 350,000 people have signed a Change.org petition demanding “justice for Harambe,” which blames Harambe’s death on “parental negligence,” insisting, “the zoo is not responsible for the child’s injuries and possible trauma.” The signatories ask for Child Protective Services to investigate the family and for the Zoo and the Cincinnati Police to “hold the parents responsible” for Harambe’s death.

As many parents of young children can intuit, the logic of this petition is questionable. It is reasonable for parents to expect a zoo to have barriers sufficient to prevent small children from entering the enclosures of dangerous animals. According to a statement made by primatologist Julia Gallucci, the design of Harambe’s enclosure was faulty: “The gorilla enclosure should have been surrounded by a secondary barrier between the humans and the animals to prevent exactly this type of incident,” she noted.

Furthermore, calling the parents “negligent” is excessive. It contradicts eyewitness accounts of how fast the little boy was.  As bystander Deirdre Lykins has reported, the boy’s mother said, “He was right here! I took a pic and his hand was in my back pocket and then gone.” Lykins said she had to stop the boy’s distraught mother from entering the enclosure.

Despite these facts, the conversation attached to the petition and elsewhere online has taken an ugly turn. Internet commentators have directed excessive vitriol at the boy’s parents and, especially, his mother. But why?

In my analysis, the hatred towards the boy’s parents reveals some unpleasant insights about widespread cultural assumptions about parenting today.

First, the call for Child Protective Services to become involved indicates an unreasonable belief that parents should be able to keep their kids safe 100% of the time. If we are being reasonable, and not lashing out in grief at the loss of a majestic primate, we know this is not possible: Kids are fast and fearless, and accidents happen.

 

And yet people supporting the petition have angrily commented, “CPS should take their kids, first thing! Obviously they can’t be bother [sic] with supervising them!” The Mirror reports even worse: that the little boy’s parents are now receiving death threats from an angry internet mob.

Many of the commenters have dwelled particularly upon the mother, harboring a tremendous amount of ill-will towards her. One commenter on the Change.org petition wrote, “This lady was obviously not paying attention to her kids! Child neglect!” Others were quick to suggest that the mother deserved to die, with another commenter writing: “The mom should have got put down for not knowing how to take care of her damn [sic] child. The gorilla was doing a better job at parenting then [sic] she was!!” People have been sharing memes on the subject via social media, with one example reading: “I was killed because a bitch wasn’t watching her child.”

Screen Shot 2016-05-31 at 3.24.30 PM

When I read words such as these, I am keenly aware that the outrage towards the little boy’s mom reveals an undercurrent of sexism and misogyny that permeate our culture.

The sexism is found in the assumption that childcare is the mother’s responsibility—an assumption that goes hand in hand with talking about dads “babysitting” their kids and “helping around the house,” when honestly, doing 50% of child care and house care is simply doing their share. Note that in most of the comments and facebook conversations I’ve read, angry remarks focus either on “the mom” or “the parents.” What about the dad, who was also there? The absence of comments criticizing the father underscores that people really believe tending children is on the mom, even if the dad is right there. Despite espousing the equality of the sexes, as a society, we still tend to hold moms to a much higher standard than we do fathers. If a dad is inept, it’s a source of comedy material; in fact, in recent days, a few posts have gone viral in which fathers have played up just how helpless and inept they are with their own kids when their wives aren’t around. People find it hilarious, and comment and share the posts laughingly–but I doubt they’d find similar commentary hilarious from a mom. We as a society still hold moms to a much higher standard than we do fathers. When we expect parents to be 100% perfect, we are really expecting moms to be 100% perfect.

The misogyny rears its head in the hateful words and ideas people are communicating. For example, the sentiment that this mother is a “bitch” who deserves to be “put down” for taking her eyes off one of her four children is misogynist. It denigrates her for failing to live up to an unreasonable standard of maternal perfection.

Meanwhile, the Daily Mail published an unjust piece dredging up the father’s criminal history, in which the article’s author even noted that “in recent years he appears to have turned his life around to become the proud father of four.” Commenters sensibly remarked that the father’s past is irrelevant to this case. As one astutely noted, “In this instance it dies not matter about his past. His child fell into a gorilla enclosure.”

And yet the piece’s most popular comment (with more than a thousand upvotes and counting), concludes by returning the focus of outrage to zoo officials and the little boy’s mom, noting: “The child’s mother and zoo officials make me sick.”

Harambe’s death is tragic, and his loss is absolutely worth mourning. But as we mourn him, let’s not victim-blame, parent-shame, or perpetuate misogyny. Harabe’s death is a wake-up call that we need to do better by the precious animals in our care. But it’s also a potent reminder that scrutinizing and shaming humanly imperfect parents does no good.

—-
Rebecca Hains, Ph.D. is a media studies professor at Salem State University and the author of The Princess Problem: Guiding Our Girls Through the Princess-Obsessed Years, a book meant to help parents raise empowered, media-literate daughters. 

Rebecca is on Facebook and Twitter. If you enjoyed this post, you may follow Rebecca’s blog by hitting the “follow blog” button at rebeccahains.com/blog.

12 Comments on “Internet mob shames mom in Harambe’s name

  1. I always appreciate your respectful approach in discussing topics like this. It does sadden me to see how many people harbor hatred instead of bestowing compassion. Whether or not you believe someone else should have done better in a given situation, we should offer grace instead of nasty threats. Kids move so fast, I feel certain that most of those criticizing the parents do not have children themselves or have lost touch with how difficult it is. I might add that shaming and blaming others during a tragedy like this is one way less self aware folks try and assert control: if I make this incident someone’s fault, I feel more in control of the world. Sadly, sometimes terrible things happen and there is no one to blame.

  2. You are 100% correct here. Racism is in play here as well, however. I have been amazed at the support for a clearly negligent zoo facility and how the shooter was just doing the only thing possible.

  3. Parents should TELL their children what to do and what NOT to do! How in the hell did he slip in the pit in the first place// The gorilla’s handler should have stepped in or other distractions to free the stupid and, obviously, disobedient child! The parent was out in another dimension and not Focused on her child !Neglect? Hell- YES, shame on her! A tranquilizer was all that was needed or a bunch of bananas! ~@EdArt9~~~~~

    • @Ed Held you either can’t comprehend what you read or just didn’t bother to read the post before commenting. It clearly answers everything you wrote about.

    • your an imbecile who obviously has never had complete responsibility for a child. EVERY parent at one point or another loses track of their kid; it’s NORMAL! What is NOT normal is enslaving animals for profit and entertainment.

      if some nitwits cant figure out how to build a proper fence then don’t allow them to operate. Better yet, free the animals. Not rocket science you misogynistic twit.

  4. This is a very sad situation, the zoo protects animals and it should be a safe place for families to go to, be relaxed have fun and not to have to restrain your children after all it is also for them to see and learn about animals..it should be child friendly..the zoo should keep up maintenance and should be a priority to check and make sure animals can’t get out and people CANNOT get in ,, the zoo had already been in trouble for slacking of on things,like not locking doors etc .The zoo is to blame..nobody should be able to climb or fall into an animal inclosure, especially a dangerous animal..sad and tragic for everyone, we’re all feeling the pain, so let’s be vigilant and make it so this never happens again 😢

  5. Parent must be prosecuted. Texting instead of wtching a child. Chimp was overwhelming with visitor yelling. Chimp wanted to save the brat misbehaved and own willed spoiled brat. Innocent gorrila paid the price. Human services must intervene with this lack of parenthood skills. Judtuct must be done…..

  6. I feel I am witnessing the ugly mob mentality magnified exponentially by reality tv. It’s like citizens of the US are just living life as one big crass, vulgar reality tv show.

  7. Good article. Sums up my own feelings about the whole,sad affair. And also reminded me of the dingo baby case in Australia – where the mother was vilified and even blamed for killing the baby herself.

Please leave a comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: